top of page
Search

A Coconut Creek Apartment Sale Closed at $196,000 a Door. Would Your NOI Survive the Buyer's Review?

Writer: Douglas Kohn, CPA
Douglas Kohn, CPA
5 days ago
6 min read

By Douglas Kohn, MBA, CPA

 

Nuveen Real Estate sold Landings at Coconut Creek, a 268-unit apartment community built in 1986, to Legacy Residential Group for $52.6 million, Commercial Observer reported on November 3, 2026. That works out to just over $196,000 per unit for a property that was 94 percent occupied, with TD Bank providing a $35.5 million acquisition loan. Nuveen had bought it for $45.3 million in 2017.

 

The broader market is still pricing South Florida apartments richly. Lee & Associates' Q3 2026 South Florida multifamily report puts the average sale cap rate at 5.90 percent, and Matthews' Miami Q3 2026 report, published November 6, has Miami at 5.43 percent. At the same time, CBRE's October Higher-for-Longer Rates brief warns that cap rates could rise 40 to 60 basis points in the near term, which it says implies average value declines of 6 to 10 percent.

 

If you are an owner in Boca Raton, South Florida or New York thinking about a 2027 sale, the cap rate is the part you can't control. The NOI the buyer is willing to believe is the part you can.

 

Why does every dollar of NOI matter so much at a sale?

 

Because the buyer divides NOI by the cap rate. At a 5.90 percent cap rate, $10,000 of NOI is worth about $169,000 of price. At 5.43 percent, it's worth about $184,000. So an adjustment that looks small on a monthly P&L becomes a six- or seven-figure number at the closing table.

 

What does a buyer actually do to my T-12?

 

They rebuild it. The trailing-12-month operating statement you hand over is the starting point, and the buyer's analyst or quality-of-earnings team adjusts it to what they think the property will earn under their ownership. The most common adjustments I see are below.

 

Management fees. A self-managed owner often runs no management fee through the books. A buyer will add one, often a few percent of collected revenue, whether or not they plan to hire a manager.

 

Property taxes. In Florida, commercial property and apartment buildings with ten or more units get reassessed at just value as of January 1 of the year after a change of ownership, under section 193.1555 of the Florida Statutes. That resets the annual cap on assessment increases for non-school levies, so a buyer will underwrite a higher tax bill than the one on your T-12. Florida voters approved Amendment 3 on November 3, 2026, which reduces that non-homestead cap from 10% to 5% beginning January 1, 2027, according to the Florida Department of Revenue. The sale still triggers a just-value reset; the new cap only limits increases after that new base is set.

 

Insurance. Buyers re-quote. If your policy is old or underinsured, expect them to replace your number with theirs.

 

Repairs that should have been capital, and capital that should have been repairs. If your roof replacement is sitting in repairs and maintenance, your NOI looks worse than it is. If routine turnover costs are being capitalized, your NOI looks better than it is, and a good buyer will find it.

 

One-time income. Lease termination fees, insurance recoveries and a catch-up of old delinquent rent are real cash, but buyers take them out because they won't repeat.

 

Collections versus billings. If the rent roll says $2.4 million but the bank deposits say $2.25 million, the buyer will capitalize the deposits.

 

What does that look like with real numbers?

 

Here is an illustrative example, not a client. Say your T-12 shows NOI of $1,200,000. The buyer adds a market management fee, rebases property taxes for the post-sale reassessment, re-quotes insurance and removes a one-time lease termination fee, and those adjustments total $150,000. Normalized NOI is now $1,050,000.

 

At a 5.90 percent cap rate, $1,200,000 of NOI supports about $20.3 million of value. $1,050,000 supports about $17.8 million. That is roughly $2.5 million of price that came down to how the books were kept and how well the owner could support each line.

 

Does a higher cap rate mean I have to write my building down?

 

Usually not. For most private owners, rental property sits on the books at cost less accumulated depreciation, not at a broker's value. A market cap-rate move doesn't by itself change the balance sheet. What it changes is the price you'll get when you sell, and that shows up as the size of your gain.

 

How do I book a sale on the accounting side?

 

There are three steps I walk owners through before and after closing.

 

Held for sale. Under GAAP (ASC 360-10), once a sale is committed and probable within a year and the property is being actively marketed, it is classified as held for sale. Depreciation stops, and the property is carried at the lower of its carrying amount or fair value less costs to sell. That classification often surprises owners because their monthly P&L suddenly loses its depreciation line.

 

The gain is against book value, not your purchase price. Here is another illustrative example. Say you bought a property in 2017 for $15 million, with $12 million allocated to the building and $3 million to land. Straight-line over 27.5 years, the building has picked up about $3.93 million of accumulated depreciation after nine years, so the carrying amount is about $11.07 million. If you sell for $20 million and pay $400,000 in selling costs, your book gain is about $8.53 million, not the $5 million difference between the purchase and sale prices. Sales of real estate to a buyer who isn't your customer generally fall under ASC 610-20.

 

Clean the closing statement. Prorated rents, tenant security deposits, property tax and insurance prorations, loan payoff, prepayment penalties and unamortized deferred financing costs all have to land in the right accounts. When this is done badly, the sale entity's final year doesn't tie out, and the K-1s and investor distributions are wrong.

 

How far ahead should I start getting my books ready?

 

Ideally 12 months before you list, because a buyer will ask for the T-12 and the trailing three and six months too. That gives you a full year of accrual-basis statements with consistent repairs-versus-capital policy, monthly bank reconciliations, a rent roll that ties to the general ledger, and support for every add-back you plan to claim.

 

When does a real estate owner need a fractional CFO for a sale?

 

When the sale is big enough that a few percent of NOI is worth more than a year of CFO fees, and that is almost every apartment or commercial sale in South Florida. A fractional CFO or fractional controller builds the seller-side package before the buyer does: a supportable T-12, a normalized NOI bridge, a rent roll that ties to the books and a closing-statement plan. If your current accounting is outsourced bookkeeping that only produces tax-basis or cash-basis reports, that's the gap a CPA-led outsourced CFO fills.

 

At Ultramar Financial, I work as a fractional CFO for real estate owners, developers and construction companies in South Florida and New York. Through SoFla Prime Consulting, I provide fractional CFO, fractional controller and outsourced accounting support for South Florida businesses and nonprofits. If you're thinking about selling in 2027, the best time to clean up the T-12 is now, while the numbers can still be fixed rather than explained. Contact me to talk through your property.

 

FAQ

 

What is a normalized NOI?

 

It's the net operating income a buyer or lender believes the property will produce going forward, after removing one-time items and rebasing costs like management fees, taxes and insurance to their ownership. It is usually lower than the seller's reported NOI.

 

Why do Florida property taxes go up after a sale?

 

Under section 193.1555 of the Florida Statutes, apartment buildings with ten or more units and commercial property are reassessed at just value as of January 1 after a change of ownership, which removes the assessment cap that had built up under the prior owner. Amendment 3, approved by Florida voters on November 3, 2026, lowers that annual non-homestead cap from 10% to 5% beginning January 1, 2027, but the sale still triggers a just-value reset; the new cap only limits increases after that new base is set.

 

Do I stop depreciating a property I'm selling?

 

Under GAAP, yes, once it meets the held-for-sale criteria in ASC 360-10. It's then carried at the lower of its carrying amount or fair value less costs to sell.

 

Is my gain on sale based on what I paid?

 

Your book gain is the net sale price minus the property's carrying amount, which is cost less accumulated depreciation. That is often much larger than the difference between your purchase and sale prices.

 

Can a fractional CFO help if I already have a CPA for taxes?

 

Yes. Your tax CPA and a fractional CFO work on different questions. The fractional CFO focuses on the monthly books, the buyer and lender package and the closing entries, and hands your tax advisor clean numbers.

 

Douglas Kohn, CPA, MBA, is a fractional CFO for real estate, construction and small businesses in South Florida and New York, through Ultramar Financial and SoFla Prime Consulting.

 

Sources

 

Commercial Observer, "Nuveen Sells South Florida Rental for $53M," November 3, 2026: https://commercialobserver.com/2026/11/nuveen-legacy-residential-landings-at-coconut-creek/

 

 

Matthews, Miami Multifamily Market Report Q3 2026, November 6, 2026: https://www.matthews.com/insights/miami-multifamily-q3-2026

 

CBRE, Higher-for-Longer Rates: Implications for Commercial Real Estate, October 2026: https://www.cbre.com/insights/briefs/higher-for-longer-rates-implications-for-commercial-real-estate

 

Florida Statutes section 193.1555 (2026): https://www.flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2026/193.1555

 

Florida Department of Revenue, Property Tax Oversight Informational Bulletin PTO-BUL-26-21, Constitutional Amendment 3 (effective January 1, 2027): https://floridarevenue.com/property/Documents/PTO_BUL_26-21.pdf

 

Florida Division of Elections, Florida Election Watch, Amendment results: https://floridaelectionwatch.gov/Amendments

 

 
 
 

Comments


Copyright © 2026 Ultramar Financial. All Rights Reserved.

bottom of page