Florida Amendment 3: What Investors, Landlords and Commercial Owners Should Do With Their Books, Pass or Fail


By Douglas Kohn, MBA, CPA
On November 3, Florida voters will decide Amendment 3, the property tax measure that expands the homestead exemption. Most of the coverage is about homeowners. But if you own rentals, a second home, a strip center, an office building or an industrial building in South Florida, the amendment touches your books too, just not in the way the headlines suggest.
I share my own view below. Either way, this post covers what the amendment actually says about non-homestead property, what the state's own estimate shows for local budgets, and what your accounting should look like whether it passes or fails.
What does Amendment 3 actually change?
It raises the homestead exemption for non-school taxes to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028, with inflation adjustments after that, according to WUWF's October 23 ballot explainer. It also lowers the annual cap on assessment increases for non-homestead property from 10% to 5% for non-school taxes, and it limits how counties and cities can spend property tax money. It needs at least 60% of the vote to pass.
Florida's Revenue Estimating Conference also points out that people who were not Florida residents as of December 31, 2026 would start with a smaller $50,000 exemption and get the larger one in their fifth year (EDR impact estimate, CS/HJR 1F). That matters if your buyers or tenants are relocating from New York or elsewhere.
Does Amendment 3 lower property taxes on rental and commercial property?
Not directly. As the Miami Herald reported on October 24, the homestead benefit doesn't apply to second homes, investor property or commercial property. What those owners get is the lower 5% cap on assessment growth, and WUWF notes that a 5% assessment cap does not guarantee your bill rises by 5% or less, because the bill also depends on the tax rate.
Could my property tax bill go up anyway?
Yes, that is the risk to plan for. The state's estimate assumes current millage rates and shows local governments losing about $4.93 billion in fiscal 2027-28 and $8.71 billion in fiscal 2028-29, growing to about $11.83 billion a year (EDR). In the Herald's October 24 renter story, Tax Foundation senior fellow Jared Walczak said local governments would likely mix spending cuts, other taxes and higher taxes on non-homestead property. He estimated that Broward landlords could pay about 15% more in property taxes if local governments fully replaced the lost revenue.
How big is the revenue gap in South Florida?
Big enough that you should assume local budget decisions will affect you. The EDR estimate includes figures for each county and city. The amounts below are the estimated non-school revenue loss for the first two fiscal years:
Miami-Dade County (all non-school levies): about $524.7 million in FY 2027-28 and $945.7 million in FY 2028-29.
Broward County (all non-school levies): about $535.7 million and $968.5 million. Fort Lauderdale alone: about $18.1 million and $33.6 million.
Palm Beach County (all non-school levies): about $418.1 million and $778.8 million. Boca Raton: about $10.3 million and $20.5 million.
Statewide, Florida TaxWatch estimates $45.8 billion in property tax cuts from 2027 to 2032, as cited by the Herald. Nobody knows yet how each city will respond. That uncertainty is exactly why your 2027 and 2028 budgets need more than one scenario.
When would owners actually feel it?
The amendment would first apply to the 2027 tax roll, with the larger exemption arriving on the 2028 roll. In practice, the first numbers you will see are the proposed millage notices in late summer 2027, then the November 2027 tax bills. Your CAM and tax estimates for tenants, your lender escrow analysis and your 2027 operating budget all get set before those numbers are final.
From my desk
I think Amendment 3 is great. I'd love no property taxes on homesteads.
That's the homeowner's side. If you also own rentals or commercial property, the rest of this post is about getting your books ready for what comes next.
What should my books look like either way?
Build three property tax scenarios, not one. For every non-homestead parcel, model (1) current law, with the 10% cap and current millage, (2) the amendment passes and millage stays flat, with the 5% cap, and (3) the amendment passes and millage or fees rise to cover part of the lost revenue. Then run each scenario through your leases, escrows and loan covenants. Here is a worked example.
Illustrative example: a hypothetical Broward NNN retail center
Everything in this example is a made-up assumption to show the mechanics. It is not a forecast for any real property or city.
Assumptions: 2026 non-school assessed value of $4,000,000. Market value grows 8% a year, so the 10% cap doesn't bind but the 5% cap does. Non-school millage of 14.0 mills. The 2026 non-school tax bill is $56,000. Tenants on true NNN leases cover 70% of the building. Another 20% is on modified gross leases with a 2026 base year, and 10% is vacant, so the owner absorbs 30% of any increase over 2026. Stabilized NOI is $400,000, annual debt service is $320,000 (DSCR of 1.25x), and the cap rate is 7%. School taxes are left out because the amendment doesn't change them.
Scenario 1, current law: 2027 assessed value is $4,320,000, so the non-school tax is $60,480 (up $4,480). The owner's 30% share is $1,344.
Scenario 2, the amendment passes and millage stays flat: the 5% cap holds assessed value to $4,200,000, so the tax is $58,800 (up $2,800). The owner's share is $840. In 2028 it would be $61,740, compared with $65,318 under current law.
Scenario 3, the amendment passes and millage rises 15% to 16.1 mills (a stress case echoing the Herald-reported Broward estimate): the tax is $67,620 (up $11,620). The owner's share is $3,486. In 2028 it would be $71,001.
What that does to the numbers in Scenario 3: NOI falls to about $396,514 and DSCR slips from 1.25x to about 1.24x. At a 7% cap rate, the hit to NOI alone is worth about $49,800 of value. NNN tenants would see about $8,134 more in reimbursable taxes in 2027 than in 2026, which is $5,000 more than they would see under current law. That is the number your tenant reconciliation and estimate letters have to support.
The takeaway: the 5% cap only helps you if your assessed value would otherwise grow faster than 5% and millage holds. If market values are flat, the cap does nothing, and any millage or fee increase flows straight through to your tenants and to the share you absorb.
What should I do with NNN and CAM reconciliations?
Re-forecast now and document your work. Update the property tax line in your 2027 CAM and tax estimates for each scenario. Check each lease for base-year stops, tax caps, gross-up language and audit rights. Plan to true up when the November 2027 bills arrive. If a tenant reimburses based on estimates, a big swing at year-end reconciliation is what starts disputes, so communicate early and keep the assessment, millage and allocation backup on file.
How does this affect lender escrows, DSCR and underwriting?
Lenders will look at it even if you don't. Tax escrows are usually sized from the prior bill, so a mid-cycle millage increase can create an escrow shortage and a catch-up payment. Run your DSCR and debt-yield covenants under Scenario 3. If you're facing a refinancing or extension, show the lender a tax sensitivity in the package rather than letting them assume the worst. Our post on CRE loan extensions and how to book fees, caps and reserves walks through the reserve side.
Should I change my valuation and cap rate assumptions?
Revisit them, but don't overreact. Buyers underwriting South Florida rentals and commercial property in 2027 and 2028 will likely stress the tax line, and higher operating expenses reduce value at any given cap rate. The Herald also quoted the Tax Foundation's Nicole Fox saying that the five-year wait for newcomers could make Florida less attractive to people moving from out of state or buying second homes. If you own Florida property from New York, keep in mind that second homes and rentals get the 5% cap, not the homestead exemption.
What if Amendment 3 fails?
Your books still need the work. Under current law, non-homestead assessments can rise up to 10% a year, and local governments are already under budget pressure. A scenario-based property tax forecast, clean reconciliations and an escrow review are good practice in any year. The amendment just makes them urgent.
Why bring in a fractional CFO for this?
Because this is a modeling problem that touches leases, loans and tax filings at the same time. A fractional CFO or fractional controller can build the parcel-by-parcel scenarios, tie them to your rent roll and lease terms, update escrows and covenant tests, and give your CPA clean support for year-end. Your CPA handles compliance and tax, and the outsourced CFO keeps the forecast and the lender story current between filings. If you're not sure you're at that stage, read When Does a Real Estate or Construction Business Need a Fractional CFO?
At Ultramar, we provide fractional CFO and outsourced accounting for real estate and construction owners in South Florida and New York. Our sister firm, SoFla Prime Consulting, provides fractional CFO, controller and accounting services for local South Florida businesses and nonprofits. Either team can build your Amendment 3 scenarios before your 2027 budget is locked.
FAQ
Do rental properties or second homes get the new homestead exemption?
No. Only qualifying primary residences get the larger homestead exemption. Rentals, second homes and commercial property get the lower 5% cap on non-school assessment growth instead.
Does Amendment 3 change school property taxes?
No. The exemption and the 5% cap apply to non-school taxes. School taxes stay in place.
When would the changes show up on my tax bill?
The changes start with the 2027 tax roll, with bills in November 2027. The larger $250,000 homestead exemption starts in 2028.
Will my city raise millage if it passes?
No one knows yet. The state estimate assumes current millage rates, and local governments could cut spending, raise other revenue or raise rates. That's why you should budget for more than one scenario.
Sources
Douglas Kohn, CPA, MBA, is a fractional CFO for real estate, construction and small businesses in South Florida and New York.
Want your Amendment 3 property tax scenarios built before your 2027 budget and CAM estimates go out? Contact Douglas at ultramarrealestate.com to set up a short video call.



Comments