South Florida Insurance Costs Fell 16%. Here's How to Build Your 2027 Property Budget Without Overstating NOI


By Douglas Kohn, MBA, CPA
Budget season is here, and South Florida real estate owners finally have one line item moving in the right direction. Property insurance costs for South Florida multifamily operators fell 16% in the 12 months ended September 2026 compared with the year before, according to Yardi data in the MIAMI REALTORS® September rental report published October 27.
The county numbers are specific. Broward fell 17.5% to $1,232 per unit. Miami-Dade fell 14.9% to $1,321 per unit. Palm Beach County fell 10.9% to $1,119 per unit. Martin and St. Lucie fell 18.9% to $1,016 per unit.
Nationally, the trend is the same. In its Q3 2026 Global Insurance Market Index, Marsh reported U.S. commercial property rates down 10% in the third quarter after a 13% drop in the second. But the same report shows U.S. casualty rates up 6%, which means your general liability and umbrella lines are still climbing while property comes down.
That split is exactly why a 2027 budget built by adding a percentage to last year's numbers will be wrong. Here's how I'd build it.
Should I budget 2027 insurance at last year's premium minus 16%?
No. The 16% is an average across a lot of buildings, and your renewal could land well above or below it. Budget from an actual renewal quote or a broker indication for your building, and if you don't have one yet, build a base case and a downside case and replace them when the policy binds.
How do I handle a mid-year insurance renewal in the budget?
Split it. If your policy renews June 1, the first five months of 2027 carry the old premium and the last seven carry the new one. On the books, the premium is a prepaid asset amortized monthly over the policy term, so the 2027 expense line is a blend of two policies, not one.
Here's an example with made-up numbers. A 100-unit building paying $150,000 a year on a policy that renews June 1 expenses $12,500 a month through May. If the renewal comes in 15% lower at $127,500, the expense drops to $10,625 a month from June on. Full-year 2027 insurance expense is $136,875, not $127,500. Budget the full renewal savings in January and your NOI is overstated by almost $9,400 for the year.
Do insurance savings go to the owner or the tenants?
On net-lease and many commercial leases, it depends on the lease. Where insurance is a recoverable expense, a lower premium lowers the tenants' estimated monthly charges and shows up in the year-end reconciliation, so a big share of the savings may never reach your NOI. Your 2027 budget should show recoverable and non-recoverable insurance separately, and your estimated CAM and insurance billings for January should already reflect the new numbers.
What does this do to my DSCR and loan covenants?
Lower operating expenses help debt service coverage, but only if the lender sees them. Many loans require an annual operating budget and a calculation of DSCR on a trailing basis, so the savings show up slowly. Run your 2027 budget through the covenant math month by month, and if your loan has an insurance escrow, check your loan documents for when the servicer re-analyzes it. An overfunded escrow is cash sitting with the lender, not in your operating account.
What else belongs in a 2027 property budget this year?
Three things I'd add. First, a reserve for your named-storm deductible, since a lower premium often comes with a different deductible structure. Second, the casualty and umbrella increases that are offsetting property savings. Third, your property tax line. On November 3, Florida voters approved Amendment 3, with 61.98% voting yes (4,922,400 yes to 3,019,415 no), according to Florida Election Watch, clearing the 60% threshold required for a constitutional amendment. The measure increases the homestead exemption for non-school taxes to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028, and it reduces the annual cap on assessment increases for non-homestead property—including rentals and commercial buildings—from 10% to 5%. It takes effect January 1, 2027, and first applies to the 2027 tax roll, according to the Florida Department of Revenue. We covered what this change means for an owner's books in our Amendment 3 post.
When does a real estate company need a fractional CFO for budgeting?
When the budget has to answer to someone other than you: a lender, an investor, a partner or a board. A fractional CFO or fractional controller builds the budget from drivers (units, leases, policies, loan terms), ties it to a monthly cash forecast, and reports budget-to-actual every month so surprises show up in March, not December.
That's the fractional CFO work we do at Ultramar for real estate and construction owners in South Florida and New York, and at SoFla Prime Consulting for South Florida small businesses and nonprofits that need a fractional CFO, fractional controller or outsourced accounting team without a full-time hire.
FAQ
How much did property insurance fall in South Florida in 2026?
For multifamily, 16% on average in the 12 months ended September 2026, per Yardi data reported by MIAMI REALTORS®. Broward fell 17.5%, Miami-Dade 14.9% and Palm Beach County 10.9%.
Are all insurance costs going down?
No. Marsh reported U.S. casualty rates up 6% in Q3 2026 even as property rates fell 10%, so liability and umbrella lines should be budgeted higher.
What's the difference between a budget and a forecast?
The budget is the plan you approve before the year starts. A forecast updates that plan with actual results and new information, usually monthly or quarterly. You need both.
Can an outsourced CFO build our 2027 budget if our bookkeeper handles the day-to-day?
Yes. A fractional CFO or outsourced controller typically works with your existing bookkeeper, building the budget, the covenant model and the monthly reporting package on top of the books they already keep.
If you own or operate real estate in Boca Raton, South Florida or New York and want a 2027 budget your lender will actually trust, contact me at Ultramar to set up a call.
Douglas Kohn, CPA, MBA, is a fractional CFO for real estate, construction and small businesses in South Florida and New York.
Sources
MIAMI REALTORS® + RWorld, "South Florida Rents Rise as Insurance Costs Fall," October 27, 2026 (Yardi data): https://www.miamirealtors.com/2026/10/27/south-florida-rents-rise-as-insurance-costs-fall/
Marsh, Global Insurance Market Index, U.S. rates, Q3 2026: https://www.marsh.com/en/services/international-placement-services/insights/us-insurance-rates.html
Florida Division of Elections, Florida Election Watch, Amendment results (Amendment 3: 4,922,400 yes / 61.98%, 3,019,415 no / 38.02%): https://floridaelectionwatch.gov/Amendments
Florida Department of Revenue, Property Tax Oversight Informational Bulletin PTO-BUL-26-21, Constitutional Amendment 3 (effective January 1, 2027; first applies to the 2027 tax roll): https://floridarevenue.com/property/Documents/PTO_BUL_26-21.pdf



Comments